Sunday, July 12, 2026

COWBOYS AND INDIANS


                                                                 
                                                                                                     
                                                      

This is a difficult time to be a Jewish person in the USA. Since October 7, 2023, both anti-Semitism and Zionism have been on the rise. Many American Jews have united to support Israel and are seeing their Judaism as almost equivalent with being pro-Israel. The American left has likewise united to support Palestinians and this has created a volatile situation in cities and universities nationally.

Just this week Rep. Ro Khanna of California, was held on the road during a visit to a Palestinian Bedouin village by armed settles and Israeli military. Rep. Khanna said that it was a terrifying experience and this also serves as more evidence of the nature of current hostilities. In the USA, feelings about Israel and the Gaza conflict have added to the existing partisan fracture in our country today. 

 As a Jewish “baby boomer” I am acutely aware of the importance of Israel to Jews world-wide. As a college student in NYC, I met many American Zionists and also visiting Israelis. As a child, I had seen graphic pictures of concentration camps and I was always aware that my grandparents were immigrants from Eastern Europe. My viewpoints were certainly biased by my leftist parents, but most of those views have changed very little over the years. I strongly feel that both American Zionists and Israeli settlers have a sense of entitlement, privilege and elitism.

 Is Israel guilty of genocide? Not my call, but there is most definitely hatred toward an entire nation of people. How can we not remember that Palestinians are descendants of a native culture and have religious roots there along with Jews?

This is how we forget: In the 1800s in the USA masses of people in the cities in the east, travelled west to seek new opportunities, and most importantly, land. Lands that had for many generations belonged to native tribes and nations. The United States government supported and encouraged this. Since the early settlement of our country, many treaties had been signed by tribal leaders and the US government—and many of those treaties were completely ignored. My generation of children played “Cowboys and Indians” and watched Western TV shows and movies that depict the “Indians” as murderous and dangerous.

 This might not be a good example, but I just watched the new “Little House on the Prairie” which is a redo of the books by Laura Ingalls Wilder. I don’t know about historical accuracy (probably flawed), but for me it was a window on how life was for the Osage Nation after losing their lands although they had lived there for many generations. (in a side note, the first oil well was drilled on Osage land in 1897 and the Nation became millionaires. Followed by a wholesale murder of their members by angry white people). The Osage, as many others, were forcibly evicted from their homes and went to “Indian Territory” designated by the US government. Were there native terrorists? Are there Palestinian terrorists? The answer is of course, yes. Is terrorism a good thing? The answer is of course, no. 

I do not believe there is an end in sight for the Israel/Palestinian conflict. Arabs in both Hamas and Hezbollah will sacrifice all for their cause. Israel will continue to exert its full weight to destroy them.  

So where does that leave me? As a post-war Jewish person I absolutely believe there is a need for Jews to have a home and feel safe. The October 7 massacre and hostage taking was horrific. But I also believe that hating and wishing to exterminate an entire race of people has and always will be horrific. In addition to it being hard to be Jewish, it is also very hard now to be an American.

No comments:

Post a Comment